The Salt
5:23 pm
Fri February 1, 2013

Where's The Beef? Burger King Finds Horsemeat In Its U.K. Patties

Originally published on Fri February 1, 2013 8:21 pm

Burger King has acknowledged this week that some of its burgers in Britain and Ireland included horsemeat, the latest development in an ongoing scandal.

Horsemeat actually contains just as much protein and far less fat than beef, according to nutritionists.

Burger King says it found trace levels of horse DNA in four samples from its Irish meat supplier, Silvercrest, but "this product was never sold to our restaurants," the company said in a statement. Nevertheless, Burger King's admission has prompted a Twitter campaign and threats of a boycott.

The horsemeat controversy is Britain's worst food scandal since mad cow disease in the 1990s. But this time around, the potential danger isn't to Britons' physical health, but their emotional well-being.

For as long as a year, British consumers who thought they were buying beef products may have been unknowingly eating pork and horse, as well.

Irish food safety officials broke the news in mid-January, when they said 23 out of 27 beef burgers sampled were found to contain pig DNA, and 10 also contained horse DNA. The meat had been marketed across the British Isles.

One beef patty, sold by the British grocery giant, Tesco, was 29 percent horsemeat.

Outside a Tesco supermarket in West London, Alicia Rodrigues, a Muslim, loads a cart with bags of groceries. She's seen the reports, and says, "It's horrible. I feel like, wow, it's horrible, horrible, horrible."

Jewish and Muslim leaders in Britain have said there's no evidence that any of the pork-contaminated beef was mislabeled as halal or kosher.

But the greatest expressions of revulsion, here in the U.K., haven't been religious. And they haven't been about pork, but horse.

Another Tesco customer, who only gave his first name, Johnny, says he's stopped buying beef burgers altogether.

"I'm not eating them any more! Poor old horses, I feel sorry for them, that's all. France and all them countries eat the horsemeat — we don't," he said.

Horsemeat is commonly eaten in France and other parts of Europe and the world. But in the U.S. and United Kingdom, horses are more often seen as companions. Indeed, to the average animal-loving, horse-mad Brit, the concept of eating Mr. Ed is abhorrent and positively un-English.

Henry Harris, the chef at Racine, a French restaurant in London, said: "There's misconception that we shouldn't be eating horse, because — the whole pet connotations and companionship that horses give people. And it puts them off. Whereas you go over to the Continent, they don't have quite the same connection. And they appreciate it more for its culinary, rather than its companion, qualities."

Most of the adulterated beef has been traced to a single Irish supplier called Silvercrest. Silvercrest seems to have acquired the suspect meat from an unapproved Polish firm.

Food critic Rose Prince says the Polish operation probably used horse for two reasons: its cheaper price and its deep red color.

"Adding it to the meat, you would certainly make it look leaner," she said. "You'd look like you're getting more, and less sort of fatty mince."

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

MELISSA BLOCK, HOST:

This is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED from NPR News. I'm Melissa Block.

AUDIE CORNISH, HOST:

And I'm Audie Cornish.

Now, a story that may turn some stomachs. It's about a food scandal in Britain and Ireland. The controversy isn't about health exactly. For as long as a year, consumers who thought they were buying beef products may have been eating pork and horse as well. Here's reporter Vicki Barker in London.

VICKI BARKER, BYLINE: It was Irish food safety officials who broke the news. They said 23 out of 27 beef burgers sampled were found to contain pig DNA, 10 also contained horse DNA, and the meat had been marketed across the British Isles.

One beef patty, sold by the British grocery giant Tesco, was 29 percent horsemeat, a level one food safety officer has called astounding. Outside a Tesco supermarket in West London, Alicia Rodrigues, a Muslim, loads a cart with bags of groceries. She's seen the reports, she says.

ALICIA RODRIGUES: It's horrible. I feel like, wow, it's horrible, horrible, horrible.

BARKER: Jewish and Muslim leaders in Britain have said there's no evidence that any of the pork-contaminated beef was mislabeled as kosher or halal. But the greatest expressions of revulsion here haven't been religious, and they haven't been about pork, but horse. Another Tesco customer, who just goes by the name Johnny, says he's stopped buying beef burgers altogether.

JOHNNY: I'm not eating them anymore. Poor old horses. I feel sorry for them, that's all. France and all them countries eat horsemeat. We don't in English.

BARKER: Indeed, to the average animal-loving, horse-mad Brit, the concept of eating Mr. Ed is abhorrent and positively un-English. Henry Harris is the chef at Racine, a French restaurant in London.

HENRY HARRIS: There's misconception that we shouldn't be eating horse because the whole pet connotations and companionship that horses give people. And it puts them off. Whereas you go over to the continent, they don't have quite the same connection, and they appreciate it more for its culinary rather than its companion qualities.

BARKER: Most of the adulterated beef has been traced to a single Irish supplier called Silvercrest. Silvercrest seems to have acquired the suspect meat from an unapproved Polish firm. Food critic Rose Prince says the Polish operation probably used horse for two reasons: its cheaper price and its deep red color.

ROSE PRINCE: Adding it to the meat, you would certainly make it look leaner. You'd look like you're getting more and less sort of fatty mince.

BARKER: Tesco supermarkets have since severed their relationship with Silvercrest. But even as the chain was pulling its compromised products of the shelves, more firms stepped forward to say they, too, had inadvertently sold adulterated beef. The most recent victim: Burger King. The burger chain's confession this week has prompted a Twitter campaign and threats of a consumer boycott.

The irony is that the adulterated products may actually have been healthier than the real thing. Nutritionists say horsemeat contains just as much protein but far less fat than beef. For NPR News, I'm Vicki Barker in London. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.